Sacrilege against a Fuel!
#11
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
My deep hatred of Fuels makes me feel no pain at the loss. I would buy pallets of SGI gear of all kinds over the years and the only time I got an entire pallet of gear where it all was bad were Fuels. Out of 22 machines I was able to get 3 working enough to sell. Of course I did get really good at swapping environment chips and I wound up with enough extra V10s to put them in O350s, so that is a plus.

Stupid power supply design, stupid scsi cable, and a front door that would actually break just sitting there. Yuk.

But like Irinikus said they could have done a much better job on the metal work. Although I am the last person to comment on cutting up an SGI.
mopar5150
Octane

Trade Count: (6)
Posts: 125
Threads: 37
Joined: May 2018
Location: Palm Springs, California
Find Reply
12-02-2023, 06:30 PM
#12
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
(12-02-2023, 06:30 PM)mopar5150 Wrote:  My deep hatred of Fuels makes me feel no pain at the loss.  I would buy pallets of SGI gear of all kinds over the years and the only time I got an entire pallet of gear where it all was bad were Fuels.  Out of 22 machines I was able to get 3 working enough to sell.  Of course I did get really good at swapping environment chips and I wound up with enough extra V10s to put them in O350s, so that is a plus.

Stupid power supply design, stupid scsi cable, and a front door that would actually break just sitting there. Yuk.

But like Irinikus said they could have done a much better job on the metal work. Although I am the last person to comment on cutting up an SGI.

And I assume, unfortunately, that the bad Fuel mainboards in your story have already go off to see the wizard?

As I'm now extremely close to being able to fix dead Fuel mainboards with total voltage failure profiles (failed 12v VRM section) that does other famage.  Now there aren't any comatose Fuels in hospital beds for me to cure.... :-(

I understand back in the day, but new demand is now up, and all the graveyard Fuels are gone.  We've no stock to fix and have now created a monster of a situation.   I really wish some dealer had hoarded dead Fuel boards for future repair....
weblacky
I play an SGI Doctor, on daytime TV.

Trade Count: (10)
Posts: 1,716
Threads: 88
Joined: Jan 2019
Location: Seattle, WA
Find Reply
12-02-2023, 06:41 PM
#13
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
I won't mind that they mod the fuel case,
but the lack of the I/O plate, the crocked graphics card and the oh so bad metal work on the V10 slot bleed my eyes.
nhattu1986
fuel

Trade Count: (0)
Posts: 17
Threads: 1
Joined: Apr 2023
Location: Vietnam
Find Reply
12-03-2023, 03:31 PM
#14
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
(12-02-2023, 06:41 PM)weblacky Wrote:  I understand back in the day, but new demand is now up, and all the graveyard Fuels are gone.  We've no stock to fix and have now created a monster of a situation. 

To be overly blunt and kind of mean but realistic : who gives a crap ? SGI boxes now are useless. Not because they can't do good work, not because they aren't the most pleasant personal computer to own and use - no. Because no one now does a damn thing of value with them. They sit on shelves looking pretty, while prices go through the roof for stuff that will never see another electron pass through its veins.

I used mine. Every single day it got turned on and work passed over its hard disk. I managed (with a lot of help from good guys) to get some open sores programs running, I used old photoshop and framemaker and pro/e and mail clients and a ton of utilities and we ran the office with a silvery apple thing and the Octane (and before that a fool and an o350).

Now that a stupid v12 costs a thousand dollars and no one does a damn thing with it, after getting their sweaty little pawprints all over it, mine, my precioussssss, wtf ? Who gives a crap ? They are pointless.

It's all become quite stupid.
hamei
broke-down old clunker

Trade Count: (0)
Posts: 380
Threads: 3
Joined: Jul 2019
Location: 上海
Find Reply
12-05-2023, 05:01 AM
#15
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
(12-05-2023, 05:01 AM)hamei Wrote:  
(12-02-2023, 06:41 PM)weblacky Wrote:  I understand back in the day, but new demand is now up, and all the graveyard Fuels are gone.  We've no stock to fix and have now created a monster of a situation. 

To be overly blunt and kind of mean but realistic : who gives a crap ? SGI boxes now are useless. Not because they can't do good work, not because they aren't the most pleasant personal computer to own and use - no. Because no one now does a damn thing of value with them. They sit on shelves looking pretty, while prices go through the roof for stuff that will never see another electron pass through its veins.

I used mine. Every single day it got turned on and work passed over its hard disk. I managed (with a lot of help from good guys) to get some open sores programs running, I used old photoshop and framemaker and pro/e and mail clients and a ton of utilities and we ran the office with a silvery apple thing and the Octane (and before that a fool and an o350).

Now that a stupid v12 costs a thousand dollars and no one does a damn thing with it, after getting their sweaty little pawprints all over it, mine, my precioussssss, wtf ? Who gives a crap ? They are pointless.

It's all become quite stupid.

Well to be even more blunt, collecting is often a passion...so arguing utility to a collector is useless. Without collectors to draw on the past and keep it alive, we'd just turn over all old things to be trashed when the new hot equipment comes out. Never remembering the way things used to be, never bringing back old ideas that were forgotten or abandoned, and never learning from those that came before through their works.  Collectors have reverence and respect for the past and the accomplishments of the past, through the items they collect.

It's nice to hear from people that were there and used them and all that.  But if you're so willing dismiss the very thing this community comes together for (Original/vintage SGI computers) then perhaps you're here for the wrong reasons.  Finding solutions and supporting collectors is our goal here.

Please consider that and perhaps take this more to heart.  SGIs are history for many computing areas...more than most other existing tech companies can even claim.  The areas they touched and the progress they made in their short window of dominance was nothing short of amazing.


It's so amazing that we even have younger people entering the collector market everyday!  What old computer platform has that kind of pull!  How many platforms can you name where people born AFTER the collapse of a tech company want to own a computer from that same defunct company? 

I'm not even sure how many "new" collectors for old companies like Commodore there are. I've only meet Commodore collectors that lived through those times.  Exclusivity and design are a factor.  But to get new members and not just be an aged community where we all just keep getting older until we slide off a cliff and all our collections are thrown away by a younger generation that doesn't get it.  No...demand is UP...UP!  

No, I think we'll stay right here and encourage people to please find/hold their dead hardware, please save what you can, call for help when you need it, and don't let a salvageable SGI station be sent to oblivion.

I hope those older forum members that were wasteful in their custodial duties of SGIs have seen the light.  Those decisions to trash failed SGI PCBs were wrong, you should have offered them for free to people online who could have researched them, or held onto them, and saw that as parts of parts, they had value.

No more throwing things out without checking, if you think "well, I own it so I can do what I want with it", while that's technically and legally true (SGI committed these sins as well...we all know it) you're socially in the wrong.  These are collectors pieces and have historic value.  If you feel you're done...then don't be an ass and try letting someone else have them for awhile so they can experience them. For collectors we all understand, we don't own these, we're just holding them for the next collector to come along to get them from us with a smile and a thank you because they will enjoy them as much as we did.  And trying to keep them running is part of that.

Being selfish is how some suppliers and some collectors got us into this mess.  Stop pretending you're producing a product, you're not...it's just trading hands and there's a limited supply...now MORE limited than we have ever seen!  If a business produces a product it makes sense to just throw away the failed units because they can always make more. Well the moment SGI cease production on their systems no more parts would've been made. Which means every part in the outside world is valuable. Because of equipment destruction, when really it should have just been passed on to someone else who was willing to hold on to it, we now have so much less inventory to try to bring back to life.  Only after advertising it freely and failing to find someone should you then recycle or donate it. 

After all if someone was just going put it in the trash then why wasn't it offered for free to just pay shipping or come pick it up? So many times someone advertises something for a price, doesn't get a sale for their price, then throws it away anyway a short time later. I've seen people destroy items rather than give them away. Selfish!

Other collectors would love a chance, give them one!

I hope this has reached everyone who had a chance to read it and reflect on not only what you currently have but what does the future look like for you and your collection. Are you just passing through or are you trying to collect them all? Are you just curious or do you have a room full of them? Whichever category you fall into remember what it took to find what you have and magnify that as time goes on. The days of finding these on pallets is pretty much over. Cherry picking is also nearly over. At this point repair is the only thing that's going to bring supply into the market.
weblacky
I play an SGI Doctor, on daytime TV.

Trade Count: (10)
Posts: 1,716
Threads: 88
Joined: Jan 2019
Location: Seattle, WA
Find Reply
12-05-2023, 06:13 AM
#16
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
Couple things to say here, and I'll try for brevity. hamei is kinda right and kinda wrong. I think applications like Shake, Pro/E, and Maya running on a higher end IRIX workstation all still have great validity. Go price out recent versions of any of that software, do you really want, as a hobbyist, to pay 10's of thousands of dollars for their so-called "modern" equivalents? At my place of employ, we use Pro/E - no wait - Wildfire - no wait - Creo, or whatever the hell the idiots at Parametric Technology have decided to rename essentially the same codebase over the years, and you know what? The version of Pro/E 2.0 that I have on my SGI's is no less capable than anything Parametric has dumped on the market since 2006. The problem with engineering, at least from my viewpoint as an admittedly "old fart," is that young engineers can't do anything using their own brainpower. They need Labview, they need Mathworks, they need Creo. Those applications do *everything* for them. Engineers I work with today talk about "my code," and I'm like, what the fuck are you talking about? You didn't write a single line of code, you used a drag 'n drop GUI builder that generated all the code for you! Sadly, none of them could write "hello world" in code, not even with a gun pointed at their heads. Basically, I weep for the future.

Project: Temporarily lost at sea
Plan: World domination! Or something...
vishnu
Tezro, Octane2, 2 x Onyx4

Trade Count: (0)
Posts: 1,250
Threads: 42
Joined: Dec 2017
Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota USA
Find Reply
12-05-2023, 09:43 AM
#17
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
Programmers are coddled nowadays. The drive towards making languages safer and wrapping all of the potential mistakes away prevents people from learning failure. It's the same people who believe that participation awards in sports are good things. The only way you can get better at something is to taste failure.

I'm the system admin of this site. Private security technician, licensed locksmith, hack of a c developer and vintage computer enthusiast. 

https://contrib.irixnet.org/raion/ -- contributions and pieces that I'm working on currently. 

https://codeberg.org/SolusRaion -- Code repos I control

Technical problems should be sent my way.
Raion
Chief IRIX Officer

Trade Count: (9)
Posts: 4,244
Threads: 534
Joined: Nov 2017
Location: Eastern Virginia
Website Find Reply
12-05-2023, 04:06 PM
#18
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
If we are to consider utility for utilities sake...
I spent an unreasonable amount of time on my work computer (dual boot FreeBSD and Windows 10) and on my phone (Librem 5) doing updates. It's a productivity drain.

Heck.. even games. I hardly ever have time to play and very often, when I get a chance, I do enjoy a bit of Flight Simulator. The other day I had one hour to play and... 40 GB UPDATE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IMPOSSIBLE TO SKIP.

Society got accustomed to accept that software can be shipped unfinished, can crash, can be shit. I think there was a lawsuit in the US in the 80s that ruled that "software engineering" is not like "aerospace engineering" or "construction engineering" in the sense that it can fail.

I spent Sunday installing a bunch of software on nextstep. So many glorious programs, with perfect functionality even today. Impressive stuff, often made by a single person. And going to "About" and seeing the names and sometimes photos of the developers always puts a smile in my face, and makes me grateful for what they did. You know... I AM SIGNING THIS THING - IT MUST HONOR MY NAME kind of attitude.

Now? Who the heck knows who coded whatever atrocity coming out of the cloud? The person behind downloading 15MB of junk before you see a single line of text? No idea.

Nothing is ever finished. Code keeps being produced for the sake of maintaining employment (from the coder's perspective) or to pursue "endless growth" (the employer).

Most of my web browsing happens on a Qubes OS laptop and, for the rest, I usually turn on an old computer. They don't get on my way of getting stuff done.

Older Mac OS? You turn the computer on, you launch the application, you work.
IRIX? You turn the computer on, you launch the application, you work.
NEXTSTEP? Solaris?
Let's say... create a PDF invoice for my employer - I can get it done in any of the platforms I mentioned faster than I can on a modern computer. Especially if I have to figure out for the 72nd time how to do the same thing because a UX designer knows better. WHERE IS THAT BUTTON?
My newish (4 years old) postscript laser printer prints from every single computer I own, full color, full duplex. My Octane loads 45mp files from my camera just fine (and I prefer the older GIMP with detached windows anyway).

A month ago, I created a flowchart of my projects on Diagram! (nextstep) and sent it to my Canon A2 printer, all good. I am also writing some C to parse

Now? Even some Linux distros!
Turn the computer on, install updates, find out that some updates require subscription (Ubuntu Pro wtf), dismiss 372 notifications, launch application, wait for smartscreen/gatekeeper to check if the application is ok (which takes many seconds depending on connection), wait for an electron glorified IRC client (teams or zoom) to eat 1GB of your memory and many more seconds before you get to write something, and experience the glory of delayed keyboard input for the first time in 30 years thanks to webapps.

We may be soon the only people left on Earth that can work on a computer efficiently.

So, I don't know, hamei... new computers render and transcode and decode faster. They transfer large files faster. The rest? Everything lags, wastes screen real estate, is usually an inconsistent eye sore.

So asking an honest question: besides Internet BS and online banking, what is it that you can't do with your collectibles? For example, Photoshop, since 7.0, has nothing really that I need, and for the last 4-5 years, nothing that I would want.
Shiunbird
Administrator

Trade Count: (1)
Posts: 553
Threads: 45
Joined: Mar 2021
Location: Czech Republic
Find Reply
12-05-2023, 05:26 PM
#19
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
Hi Shiunbird & co,

to answer your simple question. "... besides Internet BS and online banking, what is it that you can't do with your collectibles?".

My response is:
- my paid job: Spreadsheets, Slide packs, email, voice conference calls, software design (pretty much all using Windows)
- my personal & company accounting: Quicken Accounting SW + Spreadsheets
- my open source (or sores as some would say ;-) ) + work SW development: mostly all Ubuntu Linux/FreeBSD + tiny amount of IRIX
- my entertainment: online music and music
- my web hosting and blog writing: Ubuntu Linux/FreeBSD

From my perspective computing is 80% SW / 20% HW

So SGI/IRIX has mostly been a learning environment for me and rationally, many things I originally did with SGI/IRIX, I can now also do via Linux/FreeBSD.

So, I have to accept that some of the things I set out to do with SGI/IRIX like: getting better open source build process going, fixing Fuel Power Supply and just keeping these boxes going, have to take a lower priority than other stuff.

Curently there is only very limited set of things that I can uniquely do with SGI/IRIX and not with other machines, such as read/play DAT music tapes ...

BTW, Hamei has done a lot to help the SGI community over the years, in particular with Fuel from back in Nekochan days. He also supplied me with my Fuel 800 CPU at price that was aligned with old day hobby pricing not ridiculous ebay prices (USD $12,000 for Fuel!!!, you have got to be joking),

Now all those running real world use cases like GE scanners and industrial machininary using old SGI, can pipe up, but for sure the digitial media business has now moved on.

Cheers from Oz,


jwhat/John
(This post was last modified: 12-22-2023, 05:00 AM by jwhat.)
jwhat
Octane/O350/Fuel User

Trade Count: (0)
Posts: 513
Threads: 29
Joined: Jul 2018
Location: Australia
Find Reply
12-06-2023, 12:16 AM
#20
RE: Sacrilege against a Fuel!
I consider myself quite fortunate, at my place of employ, all the software we write is for our in-house use only, with the single exception that we will share our software with the government, if they really want it (rarely), but they just have to live with the fact that the only user interface software we use is Motif and they're going to have to run it on Unix, Linux, or, and I don't even really know, the "Linux software for Windows" binary, or whatever the hell Microsoft calls it. Does that even have a Motif dynamic library? I don't know and I don't care, because yeah, I'm one of those old farts who's never really used Windows for anything other than email, because that's what the company I work for has decided to use. Yeah, Outlook, what a horrendous  piece of shit. But I'm not bitter! Tongue

Project: Temporarily lost at sea
Plan: World domination! Or something...
vishnu
Tezro, Octane2, 2 x Onyx4

Trade Count: (0)
Posts: 1,250
Threads: 42
Joined: Dec 2017
Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota USA
Find Reply
12-06-2023, 02:13 AM


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)